Album
Substance
1987 · Electronic
80 collectors on Gatefold own this

Substance is an Electronic album by New Order, originally released in 1987. On Gatefold: 176 pressings tracked, owned by 80 collectors.
About
By 1987, the members of New Order were at the height of their powers. They’d released four albums of revered electronic-flavored rock that found them carrying the post-punk torch of their first band, Joy Division, while adopting dance and New Wave into their sound. And they’d let loose a series of club-centric singles inspired by New York’s thriving early-1980s post-disco, proto-house, early electro and Latin freestyle scenes—all of which helped push New Order further into the electronic dance music milieu. New Order dominated both college-rock radio and dance-music playlists. Unfortunately for fans, New Order’s music wasn’t always easy to track down. Club singles from the early 1980s—including the mammoth hit “Blue Monday”—were available only as 12-inch singles. The 1985 dance-floor classic “The Perfect Kiss” could be found on the album <i>Low-Life</i>, but only in truncated form. And 1986’s beloved “Bizarre Love Triangle” was released in a variety of versions. It was tough to collect all of the group’s smashes in one place. A solution arrived in the form of 1987’s <i>Substance</i>, a two-disc compilation that contained a treasure trove of music. Yet the band members weren’t content with simply slapping a bunch of old recordings together. <i>Substance</i> opens with a new version of “Ceremony,” a track written by the four members of Joy Division while singer Ian Curtis was still alive, and recorded in March 1981 by the three surviving musicians as the first New Order single; the <i>Substance</i> version is a re-recording featuring member Gillian Gilbert adding guitars. Other early hits, like “Temptation” and “Confusion,” appear here in new, <i>Substance</i>-specific versions. Those updates give the album a sonic consistency. It also explains why many fans consider <i>Substance</i> to be their favorite New Order “album”—and why it became the only one to achieve platinum status.
via Apple Music
The Clerk says
The Clerk knows this whole record — the pressing quirks, the credits, the take.
Tracklist
Side A
- A1Ceremony
- A2Everything's Gone Green
- A3Temptation
Side B
- B1Blue Monday
- B2Confusion
- B3Thieves Like Us
Side C
- C1The Perfect Kiss
- C2Subculture
- C3Shellshock
Side D
- D1State Of The Nation
- D2Bizarre Love Triangle
- D3True Faith
Sound DNA
- Electronic
- Synth-Pop / New Wave
- lush
- wistful
- nocturnal
Substance was the first widely released New Order compilation. Issued as a 12-track double LP, a 12-, 24- or 28-track double cassette, a 24-track double CD, and a 24-track double DAT, the compilation featured original 12" singles and B-sides, with a few exceptions.
"Ceremony" is the 1981 re-recorded version with Gillian Gilbert, "Temptation" and "Confusion" are May 1987 re-recordings, and "Subculture", "Shellshock", and "Hurt" are edited versions; CD and DAT copies additionally contain a version of "The Perfect Kiss" where the climactic finale is edited down by 44 seconds. These alterations were implemented due to storage limitations of physical media in 1987, and have remained in place on all reissues. The 2023 remaster restores "The Perfect Kiss" to its full length but leaves the other edits intact.
Additionally, all of the 24- or 28-track editions confuse the song titles "Cries and Whispers" and "Mesh" (owing to the tracks being improperly ordered on the rear sleeve for the 12" release of "Everything's Gone Green" in 1981), misname "The Perfect Kiss", "The Kiss Of Death" and "Sub-Culture" "Perfect Kiss", "Kiss Of Death" and "Subculture" (respectively), and place A-sides "Procession" and "Murder" on the second CD/DAT, which is otherwise relegated to B-sides; the latter anomaly is not present on cassette copies.
First US release: Aug. 18, 1987
Credits
The people behind it.
Production & Engineering
- New OrderPRODUCER
- New OrderWRITTEN-BY, PRODUCER
- Stephen HaguePRODUCER
- Arthur BakerPRODUCER
- Arthur BakerPRODUCER, WRITTEN-BY
- Arthur BakerPRODUCER, WRITTEN-BY [ESCRITO Y PRODUCIDO POR]
- Arthur BakerWRITTEN-BY, PRODUCER
- J.S.ZeiterENGINEER [CASSETTE TRANSFER AND EDITING]
- John RobieCO-PRODUCER
- John RobieENGINEER
- John RobieMIXED BY
- John RobiePRODUCER
Songwriting
80 collectors on Gatefold own this · 176 pressings tracked on Gatefold
Start your shelf.
Track your pressings of Substance, get the Clerk's take, and see what the record is worth — free.
Start your shelf →Free forever. Works with 10 records or 10,000.
