Album

Why Me? Why Not.

Liam Gallagher

2019 · Rock

9 collectors on Gatefold own this

Why Me? Why Not. by Liam Gallagher

Why Me? Why Not. is an Alt/Indie album by Liam Gallagher, originally released in 2019. On Gatefold: 17 pressings tracked, owned by 9 collectors.

About

After launching his solo career with 2017’s platinum-selling <i>As You Were</i>, Liam Gallagher had a simple mission statement for the follow-up: Do it again and do it better. “I’m never going to change my genre of music,” he tells Apple Music. “I know what the people who come to see me want and I know what they don’t want, so it’s very easy. I’m not trying to make <i>Sgt. Pepper</i>, I'm not trying to make <i>The Wall</i>. It is what it i. Neil Young hasn’t changed his sound for fucking 40 years and no one gets on his case. And I’m not saying I’m Neil Young, because I'm far from it.” Liam is well aware of what he is: the greatest rock ’n’ roll singer of his generation. On <i>Why Me? Why Not.</i>, his voice crackles with love, wisdom, vitriol, and hurt. He’s as magnetic as he was when Oasis was in their imperial period—and these are some of the best songs he’s been on in the last two decade. He’s thrillingly barbed on the punchy glam-rock of “Shockwave” and adrenalizing on “The River,” a set of psych-rock jumper cables for the soul. The tender moments are just as stirring, not least when he pledges enduring love for his daughter Molly on “Now That I’ve Found You.” The centerpiece is “Once,” a reflective heart-sweller with the sort of goosebump chorus that he’s been nailing for 25 year. “It’s one of those songs that you come across every couple of year, or once in your lifetime,” he say. “We had a few of them in Oasi. If Noel had wrote it or if it was going out under the Oasis name, I think a lot of people’d be creaming in their pant. It’s up there, I think, with anything Lennon’s ever done, or Pink Floyd or Bowie. I feel like I levitate when I'm singing that. So if you see me floating about up in the sky, you know I'm having a good time.” On “One of U,” he sing, “Come on, I know you want more/Come on and open your door/After it all, you’ll find out/You were always one of u.” It’s an olive branch extended to Noel—not that Liam thinks it will be accepted. “Oh, god, no. No way, man. He doesn't want to get in the ring with me again, for many reason. You know why? Because he knows that he has to share the load, and standing next to me, he becomes very, very small. He’s already fucking small. So he doesn't want that, he wants the limelight for himself. But there you go, you keep trying, don't you? I think that’ll be the last one. I’m done. I’m going to get on with me shit, man. “But I’ll still dig him out, because he needs to be dug out. And he’ll dig me out because I need to be dug out. But it is love, love, love, it’s not hate, hate, hate. I don’t hate him. I love him, you know what I mean?” The explosive end of Oasis and his subsequent band Beady Eye’s gentler winding down wasn’t what Gallagher had planned for either group. But having found two collaborators “who know exactly what I’m about”—writer-producers Greg Kurstin and Andrew Wyatt—he’s getting on with the business of being the singular, outstanding voice of big, emotive rock tune. “Listen, man, I had four years in the wilderness not doing anything,” he says of the tough time between Beady Eye and <i>As You Were</i>, which included a divorce. “I wasn't stranded in the desert with no food. I wasn't captured by the Taliban. I was in the pub getting off me tit, but, still, it was a good thing for me to get my personal life in order. You can't have an untidy house. I’ve got a lot of making up to do. As long as people want it, I'll do it, because there's nothing else to do, and it's the best gig in the fucking world.” .

via Apple Music

The Clerk says

The Clerk knows this whole record — the pressing quirks, the credits, the take.

Start your shelf to read the full take →

Open this record in GatefoldThe full album page. Every pressing and its live price unlocks with Mosh Pit.

Tracklist

Side A

  1. A1Shockwave
  2. A2One Of Us
  3. A3Once
  4. A4Now That I've Found You
  5. A5Halo
  6. A6Why Me? Why Not.

Side B

  1. B1Be Still
  2. B2Alright Now
  3. B3Meadow
  4. B4The River
  5. B5Gone

Sound DNA

  • Alt/Indie
  • Alternative Rock
  • crunchy
  • defiant
  • punky

Credits

The people behind it.

Performers

9 collectors on Gatefold own this · 17 pressings tracked on Gatefold

View this release on Discogs →

Start your shelf.

Track your pressings of Why Me? Why Not., get the Clerk's take, and see what the record is worth — free.

Start your shelf →

Free forever. Works with 10 records or 10,000.