Album
Separation Sunday
2005 · Rock
11 collectors on Gatefold own this

Separation Sunday is an Alt/Indie album by The Hold Steady, originally released in 2005. On Gatefold: 10 pressings tracked, owned by 11 collectors.
About
After The Hold Steady’s energizing 2004 debut—the short-story-collection-as-rock-record <i>Almost Killed Me</i>—the group returned in 2005 with <i>Separation Sunday</i>, an album that plays as a cohesive, somewhat experimental novel. Propelled by a borderline biblical narrative, <i>Separation Sunday</i> dives deep into the lives of lead singer Craig Finn’s recurring characters—including Holly (short for Hallelujah), Charlemagne, and Gideon—as they get into adventures (and trouble) in places like Denver, Chicago, the Twin Cities, and Ybor City. Filled with ripping rock ’n’ roll alongside Catholic imagery, resurrections, and an oftentimes drug-fueled scene, <i>Separation Sunday</i> is an original, artful record. Finn’s lyrics combine intensely specific references—he sings about actual streets, neighborhoods, and bands—with completely unreliable narration. He was telling an ongoing fictional story that felt very much encapsulated within reality, building a years-long lore that Hold Steady fans would still be debating and discussing years later. And on <i>Separation Sunday</i>, the band is doing some boundary-bending work of its own, pulling together punk rock, classic rock, bar rock, and mid-2000s indie rock to create a dynamic sound, with keyboardist and multi-instrumentalist Franz Nicolay joining in as a full-time member. The result is a raw, energetic collection of modern-day hymns, one that found The Hold Steady finding critical acclaim—and landing the group on the cover of <i>The Village Voice</i>, the first rock act to do so in 15 years.
via Apple Music
The Clerk says
The Clerk knows this whole record — the pressing quirks, the credits, the take.
Tracklist
- 1Hornets! Hornets!4:46
- 2Cattle And The Creeping Things3:45
- 3Your Little Hoodrat Friend3:52
- 4Banging Camp4:14
- 5Charlemagne In Sweatpants3:57
- 6Stevie Nix5:26
- 7Multitude Of Casualties3:04
- 8Don't Let Me Explode2:21
- 9Chicago Seemed Tired Last Night3:18
- 10Crucifixion Cruise1:49
- 11How A Resurrection Really Feels5:32
Sound DNA
- Alt/Indie
- Indie Rock
- gritty
- rowdy
- storytelling
Notes from the original pressing. Later editions may differ.
The Hold Steady: Craig Finn, Tad Kubler, Galen Polivka, Franz Nicolay, Bobby Drake, Judd Counsell.
Recorded at Atomic Recording Co. (Brooklyn) and Gigantic Studios (Manhattan).
Credits
The people behind it.
Performers
- Alan FerberHORNS
- Bobby DrakeDRUMS
- Craig FinnGUITAR VOCALS
- Franz NicolayKEYBOARDS
- Galen PolivkaBASS
- Judd CounsellDRUMS
- Nicole WillsVOCALS
- Peter HessHORNS
- Tad KublerGUITAR
- Tim ByrnesHORNS
11 collectors on Gatefold own this · 10 pressings tracked on Gatefold
Start your shelf.
Track your pressings of Separation Sunday, get the Clerk's take, and see what the record is worth — free.
Start your shelf →Free forever. Works with 10 records or 10,000.
